Muheddine et al. spectroscopy of deprotonated chlorophyll anions at 9K in Orsay, France; similar spectra to neutral pigments in solution

Muheddine et al. spectroscopy of deprotonated chlorophyll anions at 9K in Orsay, France; similar spectra to neutral pigments in solution

Spectroscopy of deprotonated anions of cold chlorophyll pigments, an approach to their photosynthetic properties.

A. Muheddine1, B. Robert2, N. Shafizadeh1, B. Soep1

1 Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Institut des Sciences Moléculaires d’Orsay (ISMO), Batiment 520 Rue André Rivière 91405, Orsay, France . 2 Université Paris-Saclay, CEA, CNRS, Institute for Integrative Biology of the Cell (I2BC), 91198, Gif-sur-Yvette, France.

Abstract We introduce here a new approach to the study of isolated chlorophyll pigments with the electronic spectroscopy of their deprotonated anions in a cold environment at 9K. These anions are isoelectronic to the corresponding neutral molecules, therefore their electronic properties are comparable. This comparison is pursued through this article. The electronic spectrum of the Q bands of deprotonated pheophorbide and methyl pheophorbide are recorded by resonant two photon electron detachment with vibrational resolution and show well-resolved bands extending through the visible spectrum in a very similar fashion to their neutral counterparts in solution. The results are compared with data of neutral pheophytin obtained by fluorescence line narrowing spectroscopy at 4K and resonance Raman spectroscopy and found very similar. The theoretical analysis is achieved by density functional (ground state DFT B97XD, hybrid exchange-correlation functionals and 6-311++G(d,p) basis sets) and time dependent density functional (TDDFT) calculations. The comparison of the active orbitals in the Q transitions shows a great similarity between neutral and anionic forms together with some orbital and related level inversions. The vibronic spectra are simulated by Franck-Condon calculations to assign the dominant transitions of the electronic spectrum. Globally, this is a new perspective in the electronic spectroscopy of chlorophyll pigments that has been opened.

Introduction

The heart of photosynthesis is a charge separation process in a reaction centre activated by light energy collected by antennas. Chlorophyll a pigments are at the centre of this process as they perform most of the light collection and excitation energy transfer in the antenna proteins, as well as charge separation and the first electron transfers in photosystems I and II, ultimately resulting into production of ATP and NADPH, the two cofactors necessary for the reduction of carbon dioxide into sugars. In the reaction centres the charge separation and the subsequent electron transfers occur with a surprisingly high quantum yield, close to unity. In photosystem II charge separation occurs in a special pair of chlorophylls and is rapidly transferred to a pheophytin (a demetalated chlorophyll), through a neighbouring chlorophyll a. There has been in the recent years a series of thorough measurements on reaction centers by 2D spectroscopy and its variants to unravel the reaction paths of primary charge separation in photosystem II 1-3 that underscored the absorption by exciton states of the chlorophyll special pair, a chlorophyll and a pheophytin. While a reaction scheme emerges with well identified steps3, modelling is hampered by the lack of precise experimental data on the spectroscopy of chlorophylls. The precise mechanism of charge separation in impulse driven experiments is still under examination. A possible mechanism involves a low frequency vibrational mode would drive an exciton pair to a charge separated state through a resonance with a high efficiency,1,4 as required in natural systems. Through many years, it was understood that spectroscopy is essential for deciphering this mechanism5-12 inspecting vibrational electronic structure or vibronic couplings. While resonance Raman has been a tool of choice to detail the electronic ground state vibrational structure of chlorophyll systems within reaction centres and antennas, the information on the detailed vibronic structure of the first excited electronic states of chlorophyll pigments is scarce and has been up to now addressed experimentally by only two groups in solid solutions at 4K by site selective spectroscopy 8,13 and by spectral hole burning 11,12,14. These experiments yielded a body of information on the vibronic properties of the ground- and first electronically excited states of chlorophylls in biologically active media. Several experiments have tracked the spectroscopy of chlorophyll in the gas phase in neutral chlorophyll15 and chlorophyll tagged with ions positive or negative16-18. However, the latter tagging method fails to capture the low frequency vibrations, while matrix measurements (site selective or hole burning) probe pigments 5 or 6-coordinated with a solvent.

We endeavour here to use a new methodology in the gas phase that will capture the whole visible electronically excited spectrum of chlorophyll pigments devoid of interaction with solvents, given the fact that the solvent interactions are important for chlorophylls19,20. To this end, we study here deprotonated anions of chlorophyll pigments which bear a negative charge away from the chlorophyll core orbitals as depicted for example by Tsujimura et al21, rationalising observations of deprotonated anions of chlorophyll C1 and C2 in diatom algae 22,23. In effect, the spectra of these chlorophylls are strikingly similar in their protonated and deprotonated forms despite the fact that the acrylate group at position 7 is conjugated to the porphyrin cycle ( see Figure 1 for the generic pigment depiction). This shows that studying deprotonated chlorophyll pigments may constitute a way of addressing their neutral state properties in the gas phase. Although the involvement of deprotonated chlorophyll c in the antennas of diatoms in vivo is not formally assessed, it suggests the potential importance of negative ions in photosynthetic mechanisms. The essential pigments in the primary reaction centres are chlorophylls and pheophytin a, a demetalleted chlorophyll a. In this paper, we concentrate our studies on the latter molecule as deprotonated anion since the vibronic coupling between Qx and Qy excited states is weak and the states well separated. This will allow applying the findings to the more overlapped chlorophyll transitions5. We report here the first observation of cooled, vibrationally resolved electronic spectra of the first electronic transitions of pheophorbide and methyl pheophorbide in their anionic deprotonated states. These molecules are closely related to pheophytin a, with only modifications on the non-conjugated phytyl chain of pheophytin a (Figures 1 a,b).

a)

b)

c)

Figure 1 : structures of the deprotonated methyl pheophorbide a), deprotonated pheophorbide b), deprotonated chlorophyll C2 c). H N NH N NH O O O O O– N N N N Mg O O O O O – I II III IV V a b c d 7d 8a 11 12 a 13 14 b 15 16 17 18 d N NHHHHHHHHHHHHH H N 1 1a 3 5 5a 2 2a 2b 4 NH 4a 4b 3a g 6 9 O 10 O 10a O 10b 7 7a 7b 7c O O (–) 8

The latter anions are isoelectronic to the respective neutrals pheophorbide, methyl pheophorbide and Chlorophyl C2 through the removal of a proton. However the extra charge is located in different positions in these molecules as documented by former photodetachment threshold experiments 24. On deprotonated methyl pheophorbide it is located on C10 (Figure 1a), on pheophorbide and chlorophyll C2 it is located essentialy on the carboxylate of the C7 chain (Figures 1b,c). We provide here detailed vibrational information on the excited states of pheophorbide and methyl pheophorbide deprotonated anions. We find and analyse intense transitions at low frequencies especially at 368 cm-1 close to the proposed coupling vibration for charge transfer, 340 cm-1 4. This study shows that photodetachment action spectroscopy, associated to simulations, yields detailed information on the excited electronic properties of these deprotonated pigments and by extension on the excited states of neutral chlorophyll pigments.

Experimental The photodetachment spectrometer has been detailed in a previous paper 24. Briefly, gas phase deprotonated anions are produced from a nano ESI ion source (Thermo Fischer, model LCQ DECA XP Plus). They are stored in an octupole ion trap for 100 ms, then pulse extracted and directed into a 3D quadrupole ion trap cryogenically cooled at 9 K. A gas pulse of helium is sent into the trap 5ms before the arrival of the ion bunch. It allows cooling the ions after the gas has equilibrated with the trap. From model developed by Delahaye 25 the ultimate equilibrium temperature should be twice the gas temperature, ~20K. Effective cooling has been checked by the width of rotationally resolved spectra (fluorophenolate) and also by the appearance of clusters of deprotonated pheophorbides with the background nitrogen/oxygen gas entrained by the electrospray process. Such clusters with low binding energies are only formed at low temperatures in seeded beams around 30K. It should be noted that for large molecules rotational broadening becomes a less severe effect compared to vibrational broadening: the rotational envelope of a single vibronic transition at constant temperature should decrease with 1/(B)1/2, where B is the rotational constant of the molecule. Thereby rotational broadening should be less compared to smaller anions, ~ 20 cm-1 26. After 80 ms, the cooled ions are pulsed extracted and accelerated to 1800 V in a Wiley- McLaren configuration for time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Then, after pulse extraction from the cryotrap, the ions are spatially (≈0.6 mm) and temporally (30 ns) focused onto the detection

devices: the VMI imager for electron detachment and a MCP direct negative ion detector. The anions are photodetached by a 5 ns OPO laser (Horizon Continuum & NT342 EKSPLA) focused on a 0.5 mm diameter, which overlaps the 0.6 mm spatial spread of the 30 ns ion packet travelling at 2.104 m/s. Laser energy is limited to 1-5mJ and neutral density filters can be added. The excitation scheme is sequential where a first photon is resonant with a vibrational state of an electronically excited anion that is photodetached by a second photon of the same color by the same laser pulse. The images of the velocity distributions of the detached electrons are either transformed by the PBasex procedure 27and the transformed image is either integrated in a suitable energy range, or integrated without transformation over the whole velocity range of the VMI image.. Spectra are recorded at 0.2 nm (at 500 nm) or 0.5 nm (at 700 nm) intervals for 30 to 40s. This involves a frequency step around 10 cm-1 and is smaller than a common rotational envelope of the anions in the range of 20 cm-1 at 20K, that is the typical rotational temperature with such a collision cryocooled system28. For our systems, which are much larger than most of the spectroscopically observed deprotonated anions, the rotational envelope should be reduced at the same 20K temperature with the inverse of the inertial moment square root of the anion. Thus no increase of the linewitdth is expected for these anions and the narrowest observed transitions contains at least 3 frequency steps. The average laser intensity is recorded in this time interval and used to normalize the electron signal by the square of its value through the spectrum (two photon process). The ion signal is also integrated through the step duration and normalizes the electron signal. Calculation methods All calculations are done using the GAUSSIAN 16 program.29 The ground state equilibrium geometries as well as harmonic vibrational frequencies have been calculated for the singlet closed shell deprotonated species ([A-H]-). We chose to work with the CAM-B3LYP30 and B97X-D3, hybrid exchange-corre